View Full Version : Supergirl V2

08-05-2017, 01:13 AM
After hearing some feedback on other pieces, I finished the Supergirl I posted in another thread. I may keep going....


08-05-2017, 02:11 AM
When I saw the title of the thread, I knew I was gonna like what I saw before I even clicked on it, Cesare! The first incarnation was good; this one is even better! I'm glad to see Kara doesn't have the big tumor on her leg anymore! ;)

I think you buxomed her up a bit, which is good; my only complaint with the current TV Supergirl is she IS a bit lacking in a couple of assets, but that's only cosmetic stuff.

Shadows and light are great; looks like there's only one light source, which is good and I have always liked the slightly upturned face; not an easy angle to pull off successfully, but you do a fine job. Love the variations in line weight, as well, in both her hair and costume, but also in the sort of outline effect you have going around the whole figure; makes it pop nicely.

Nit picky time 'cause I can't be a Capricorn and NOT be nit picky. Her right hand/wrist area still seems a little to thin, like there's not indication of where her wrist ends and her hand begins. Also, watch the curve on the right shoulder; it's pretty bulbous compared to her left. Shoulders are generally pretty narrow, even on female sooper heroes. If you could move some of the bulk from her shoulders to her hips and widen them up just a touch, she would look even better as women's hips are oft times one of their greatest assets as is the gluteus maximus the hips make swing around oh-so nicely! Only other observation is, with the angle her left foot and leg are at, seems like to might see a little more of the heel on her boot.

Besides all that, this art makes me happy!!

08-05-2017, 02:50 AM
that shoulder, yeah......the foot, yes, maybe....

08-05-2017, 11:11 AM
The Capes and how the hair cuts the cape off is wonky. The flapping cape doesn't look as if it's attached. the lines don't flow from shoulders to full cape. Plus if the winds strong enough to move the cape that much her hair would also be flowing .

08-05-2017, 02:08 PM
Good crits

lesson learned, be honest with your work and open minded

This one is done regardless


08-05-2017, 03:05 PM
nice rendering.

08-05-2017, 06:20 PM
Heres a good reference to fix that pose issue.


salvador raga
08-05-2017, 10:30 PM
I like it!

08-06-2017, 01:16 AM
Heres a good reference to fix that pose issue.


That is one boring pose, terrible choice. What pose issue are you referring to?

08-06-2017, 02:09 AM

08-06-2017, 06:50 PM
the comparison doesnt apply to the extreme curve of my pose.......the real problem is her right leg should appear a little farther back, and I don't think I achieved that illusion...

good lesson though

08-06-2017, 10:49 PM

The extreme curve doesn't dictate the perspective of the leg the direction the hip is pointing does. No matter how extreme. The weight of the body has to be distributed correctly of the body can't stand in its stance. The left hip would have to come forward to push the other leg back in perspective.


https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/OT0-mTcjrNc4GGDphl0nDaNtaSew_rByjRSHc1pwhc7ub-AXyUFyzyRoLKTTniXfRLtFJOcDAUzoyPPyRm1N55dyNgjm1m8Z 5KG9rdSWO_dmQJmMSjYxROQTEF8BXkGVkElU51yy4tNJ51rmZ5 Mo-YvTkFjsJ0fhzXQtJ1g72a6gecp1VNaZdRsw9-a1Xz-NJT1Mt8GThyH1uDrFwq3n6Fn--c0e6cK-EKJUlraW909gG7fdcmKzXvgHjij67QcqRGEpLh1ISDw1Hhp9uw cAr_vWC7p9js-AiEer3SdFSZUPQmz2sJKtxF_ytAh5-nCVzOUh4GNma3IXX6lsxG2BZBXkqh9gizcy47EzJtHCw8gOLjY zIACkGKGn9WAqTl8yXOB5AaPH0JnfZ62f5qbY_5h984aqLbpks OBcGrgvUnRqv84k502XeYLrVaTYZRClLpCjK0pd0zrTHWYJ7KH KrVLgf8BzMJY5OY2bWzYF28RSxeyfeGIMMVYWQUGgV1HdS0RCQ cghTnw8MBNul9K4LekfrRtFytKv2ZxGmi6HmQ2Wt2sRoohpyYE OpUATOfmM_4EtMeUZVJSw-Vl1vBZLrbhqxmgm3K9n9BTUbJnVVyq9xQMncy_OaNN0=w300-h470-no

08-06-2017, 11:27 PM
you're forcing the issue, the pose of the character isn't a problem, why are you trying so hard to make your point....??
your diagram doesnt make sense either....the one with the overlays....


08-16-2017, 03:21 PM
I think it's looks good, good stance a bit dynamic... it works, good drawing!